Scott F.

Congrats on the early successes. I was a really big eater before. It would nothing to eat my steak, a loaded baked potato several glasses of sweet tea and then finish maybe half of my wife's steak as well. Shortly thereafter I could a huge bowl of ice cream before bed. I could eat chicken wings faster than they could be delivered. Since being 4+ months into the carnivore approach it all I can do to eat a 12-14oz ribeye. If I do burgers I can hardly get down two large patties. It is funny that now I'm pretty much never what one would call 'hungry'. Again, welcome and best of luck. Scott

Even n the 50's it was called the 'meat only diet' and some even called it the Stone Age diet'. "Carnivore" is just the newest name and this one markets incredibly well. I think Dr. Shawn Baker gets a lot of the credit for the name. He wrote a book and the name took off from there. But I am sure the diet has been used for years but with different names. Dr. Shawn Baker, Dr. Eric Berry and Dr. Chaffee offer some really good information on their You tube videos. The diet showed great successes with the Multiple Sclerosis community many years ago. It was called the "red meat and water diet" which would be a tough sell marketing wise. Good luck as you move forward. Scott

We are the 'house divided' as well. My wife is not onboard with the idea of going carnivore. She is seeing the effects/results I am having but simply won't give up vegetables. What works for us is cooking slightly more meats than we would normally cook for dinner. She has her sides, I do the carnivore thing and then there is meat left for me to take to work the following day. For the most part I eat once per day. Juggling the two of us on two or three meals a day would add to the degree of difficulty. Thus far it has worked out well. Scott

I might try the goat's milk. I never tried it myself but used a bunch of it with young puppies. They like it. LOL Scott

True. In the past four months I have a number of stalls. None lasted more than a few days (understanding I was 306 with a lot of fat and the fat was falling fast/stalls not for any real length). At 244 I still have a lot of fat but this stall has lasted nearly 2 weeks. The only thing that changed was that I started drinking milk here and there and then it became semi-regular. It was never more than a glass, mostly in the morning, but occasionally at night. After about a week or so drinking milk, with no other real changes I stalled. I guess I was use to the "stall" being relatively short-lived so when it got to a week or so and then longer, I put it on the milk. When I am on dayshift my one meal a day is at night a lot of times. I found this interesting.

No doubts. Time will tell. Scott

I have stalled around 62lbs for about a week/two weeks or so. I still feel good, lots of energy and the workouts are better and better. No real complaints. For some background, if you pick the finest restaurant you can find, come up with the best steak ever, the best smoked ribs, you name it....and I would trade it for a cold glass of milk and a peanut butter/jelly sandwich. I'm simple, and milk with a PBJ is tops. (sad, but true, LOL) I recently reintroduced milk three to four times per week. One glass, usually early in the morning and on occasion at night before bed. Everything else seems fine but the weight loss stalled. I hit 60lbs at the end of August/early September and have been there since with all else the same. As my luck would have it, the first thing I reintroduce is something I will eliminate again. Go figure. I will go a stretch without it and see if things pick back up. Like most things, time will tell. Scott

Dr. Berry, Dr. Shawn Baker and Dr. Chaffe on youtube have a tone of information about most every thing carnivore related. Sort of contradictory to my first post but these youtube videos are super informative. Lotsof information available. Scott

Welcome and hope the diet works for you. The diet is much more about the elimination of foods than what you actually eat. What you eat is pretty simple, meats salt and water. For some the diet becomes akin to religion and like religion, some see things differently. When I started I had just bought a 12 pack of Mountain Dews and a tub of ice cream. Tossing those out or wasting them at them time was not going to happen. My first week I had the eating part right but I finished off the soft drinks and ice cream so I didn't truly start eliminating til five or six days later. I went for a stretch using the drink mixes as I was not a big water drinker. The carnivore diet has worked for me thus far, just over four months. I have found that I do better and feel better on red meats, salt and water. I do eat other meats, chicken, fish and pork, but mostly red meats. As for your inflammation, I too have/had similar issues with an autoimmune disease. I was on gabapentin (neurotin) and prednisone since 2018. In less than a month of elimination the pain and stiffness disappeared. As you get started read about fat content and electrolytes. The first thing we think of is just eating meats but fat and electrolytes are the two drivers of the carnivore diet. I should have lead off with 'just four months' because I am in the infancy of the diet. At some point it will become a lifestyle at least that is my working goal right now. This is a great place to ask questions. it is 'real' people giving their personal experiences which for me, is much better than a medical study or a youtube video that says "make sure you click, and subscribe and use my code when you purchase from my sponsor....I feel like those have an agenda. Here, I don't feel the 'agenda' when people post. That is just me tho. Best of luck going forward. Scott

Thanks. I'm not sure if the 'feeling better on red meats' is associated with the autoimmune disease as the "red meat and water diet" was used int eh fifties for Multiple Sclerosis. Not sure, but I think I want to give it a try. So many things smelled good and as I checked them out I passed on the ones with the sauces already applied. My sauces I used in the past had a staple of sugar/brown sugar. I passed. It sure smelled good though. Scott

I'm not where I want to be but really grateful for where I am right now. I have lost 60lbs/120 days (62 yesterday but there was a Hot Sauce festival near here and a lot of food trucks. I walked and walked til the sniff test said pull in. First trip was a rack of 8 large shrimp off the grill. The vendor was thrown for a loop when I bought the shrimp but declined on his "famous sauce" at the Hot Sauce festival. As we walked the sniff test pulled me over to a pork truck. I ate a pint of chopped pork BBQ. Again, the lack of sauce was damn near frowned upon, LOL) The last few days I have noticed the three-to-four-mile walks are finishing up a few minutes early. I'm feeling better while moving at a better pace. Along the way I do squats and the second half of a burpee, I walk a few feet and then do ten push-ups. Today I did 8 sets on the walk for a total of 95 squats and 80 push-ups. It is actually getting easier. Still no need for the pain nor the inflammation medicine. The bloodwork last week was not all that bad. Of course, I wanted world class results after 100 days, but all things considered I'm rather happy with those results. I stumbled upon a doctor who seems more excited about my results than I am, even to the point she promised to be well versed for our next visit in Oct/Nov. My next step is to figure out to get to only red meat, salt and water for a stretch. The wife not being carnivore offers up a bit of a challenge but maybe with some pre-cooking/re-heating I will be able to figure it out. Sort of using the board as a journal. My apologies for blabbing. Scott

Congrats on the progress. I hit some energy issues early on but for me it was fats and electrolytes. The weight was falling really fast as I was on a pound a day stretch for a hair over 30 days. My guess is as became more and more fat adaptive I needed more electrolytes, maybe more fat and not as much lean protein. Since I didn't read any instructions early on I stumbled through the first month or so. I'm much heavier on the fats now and I use the electrolyte solution to salt my food, sometimes sort of heavy. Since, my energy levels have been far above where they were pre-carnivore. Congrats on the new pup. We lost our English Bulldog after 16.5 years just this past week. I had a recliner, not sure of the brand, but it was called the beast. She would jump into the recliner, wedge herself in and the three of us, me, her and the recliner, would totally ruin a Saturday. Good times. At some point the innocence and energy of a new puppy will be a good thing for us too... Best of luck and congrats. Scott

https://www.msn.com/en-us/video/webcontent/web-content/vi-AN1qqhjkQ%2FW2yA?vid=mUuie1W2NqE&provider=yt&ocid=msedgdhp&pc=HCTS&cvid=832e739c053541a28cc240cb4a5278d4&ei=198 This one popped up earlier. Scott

I just turned 55. I started May 8th. I have an autoimmune disease called NMO/SD, similar to Multiple Sclerosis. Withing three to four weeks on the diet I found I no longer needed the pain and inflammation medicine I had been on since 2018. I started off at 306 and this morning I was 244. 62lbs in less than four months. I only have positives thus far. I had some loose stool issues in the beginning but not really any different than any 'hard switch' in a diet. I didn't have the 'carnivore flu' like some do. All positives. Good luck. This is a pretty good place to learn and ask questions, at least I like hearing from real people vs. reading medical studies. (it seems they all have an agenda). Scott

I'm eating meats, salt and water. The variety I get is because my wife is not digging the carnivore approach. I try to stay heavy on the red fatty meats and my variety comes when she can't/won't do red meats that night. Lat night was grilled salmon and shrimp. I have an autoimmune disease called NMO/SD, really similar to Multiple Sclerosis, but it attacks the eyes. The lesions and infusions are really similar. I do feel like I do better on red meats than other meats. After about three to four weeks I no longer needed my pain or inflammation (gabapentin and prednisone since 2018) Like Bob said, try to cook/prepare the same meats in different ways. I like burger but a lot of times I grind my own adding more fat. Instead of a 73/27 burger I go 60/40 and even made some 50/50 burgers. I liked them a lot but it might be too much for some. I grill them at times, pan fry them in a skillet and sometimes I make it lot taco meat and add cheese/eat it out of a bowl. As of late I have been on beef riblets (Sam's Club) and they are now my new 'go to'. They are fatty, cook rather quickly/easily, and taste amazing. I then keep the bones and make a bone broth to drink or cook with at a later time. Another route is youtube. It seems like there a million carnivore recipes on there. I have planned to build a carnivore pizza for the longest but can't ever seem to get that done. Best of luck with the new approach. Thoughts and prayer to you and yours. Scott

I have had one appointment since starting. My regular family doctor was out and the new doctor filled in for my appointment. She was super supportive. It seemed like I did most of the talking and she seemed really interested. She told me she was not completely familiar with the diet but she would be well versed on the next appointment. She also said that she was not a doctor who thought everything needed a pill. She was impressed with my results and even asked if she could add a couple more things to my next set of labs to help her understand. I went in expecting a lecture on how this approach is a horrible idea. To my surprise, she said people having been curing, as well as creating disease, with food since the dawn of time. I told my wife this doctor is going to be my new doctor. My first was very positive. My next appointment is with my neurologist in November. We will see. Scott

I'm not sure I changed anything. I feel like my salt and water intake has been as normal. I skipped a day at the gym and our local temperatures have dropped considerably since the upper 90's stretch we had the last couple months. With that said the last two nights and in some in the days I have had cramps all over. Both my upper and lower legs. My hands and fingers. In my side. I'm drinking a boat load of water today and either I missed a bottle or two or maybe it is another 'adjustment' as the weight continues to fall. First set of cramps I have had since switching. First mustard I have had in months. It relieved the cramps but it sure didn't taste like what mustard taste like before. LOL Scott

Congrats on your accomplishments thus far. I'm carnivore since early May. I've only had positives thus far. I'm off the prednisone and gabapentin/neurotin after only a few weeks. I'm down 60 pounds since May 8th. Exactly what is a "meat up"? Scott

After three or four weeks the inflammation issues I have had since being diagnosed with NMO/SD just eased away without me actually noticing. I basically just thought I haven't taken any medicine this week and then it sort of came together. I have not had any issues that would have resulted in swelling so no real information. I would guess if you have been on carnivore for awhile your body is not fighting off all the other crap so when there is an actual issue you are better prepped??? Just spit balling on this one. Scott

Many factors. I can only speak from personal experience. When I first started I didn't hit my fat to meat ratios and I was flat. As soon as I got that sort of straightened out I was not getting enough electrolytes. When lacking in either/both I felt flat. I was just getting back into the gym and I didn't have a lot of energy. Once I got them both correct my energy levels went up. I have not had a lot of soreness issues. I don't lift super heavy. I feel a tad bit tight on the 'heavier' days but have not experienced a lot of soreness. I would say up your fat content. The fattier cuts of meat always help. I cook in butter and beef tallow. When I use the crock pot I try to drink the liquids. I cook bacon first and then just add the eggs into the bacon and bacon grease. I'm no expert. Scott

Supplement with a potassium included electrolyte. I forget her name but go to youtube-homemamde electrolytes- and her name is Teri G. It is as about as simple a mixture as out there. I started off trying to make drinks with it but not much on the salty taste when drinking. I use it to liberally salt my foods. Hope it works out for you. Scott

I take Vitamin D and magnesium. I have always had low Vitamin D even with supplementation. Since Carnivore, with the supplementation, I am back in the "green". I don't see a problem with it as during the switch they are more than likely needed. I wish I had read the directions or asked the questions. I stumbled thru and had some issues that were easily avoidable. The magnesium may have prevented a few of the "pinch and sprint" trips to the bathroom. I'm not smart like that tho, just seem to wing it. Best of luck. This is a good place to ask and learn. Scott

Congrats on the progress. Agree with Bob's post as well. I'm on that same plan but it is not by intention. Somedays I eat a little more than others, it is nothing really set as far as counting calories. My weight will swing up and down into what seems like a 'moving stall'. When I happen to eat lighter for a day or so I drop weight fast, five to six pounds in a three- or four-day span. Then the moving stall happens again. I guess until Bob's post I didn't know that was a 'thing'. Learning everyday. Scott

Hope it works out for you. I'm on the other end of the spectrum....you skinny people have "champagne problems". LOL Scott

I'm on the other end of that spectrum. No real input from me. If I took a stab at it I would say increase the fat content to the point you are no longer in a calorie deficit. You could even be the candidate for supplementation. Most every one says the carnivore diet does not need the protein additives. Maybe try to eat a surplus amount of fatty meat/heavily fatted and then use the shakes to get the protein. Again, I started off at 306 pounds. Just tossing out a guess. No real experience. Scott