Scott F.

Again, I try not go down the road of the conspiracy theorists, although it can be quite entertaining. Breaking down the facial recognition of the guy in this picture and the guy on the stairs....two different people. Nose structure is different. Chin is different. Ears are different. Sort of makes me take pause. Scott

I thought sugar withdrawals would be something difficult. No board sent me for a loop. LOL Scott

Welcome, and congrats on your and your wife's progresses. We are in similar boats. I lost 30-31 pounds in 31-32 days to get started and after 18 months I am around 95 pounds lost. My wife has started and stopped a couple different times and started off with 7-8lbs the first couple weeks and then sort of planed off with not much showing on the scale. The first rule of thumb is not to use the scale as a measuring device. (listen to what I say, not what I do, because I can't help myself, LOL) Sometimes the weight will stay the same but the body composition will change. As my weight dropped I could go a week or so with no change in the scale, bouncing up and down a couple three pounds but at the same time I would have to cinch up my belt a notch or two. The scale said one thing but my pants were a tad bit baggier. Secondly, sometimes the weight falls off fast and the metabolic changes come after some time. And the reverse can be true as well. The weight sort of hangs out while the body is healing. Everyone handles dairy differently. Some frown upon it while eating carnivore and others it is no big deal. I still drink milk on occasion, not a ton but some a couple three times per week. For me, as an individual if my weight were falling, both on the scale and in composition, it was like a glass of milk would put the breaks on the fall and send me into what most call a 'stall'. I'm not opposed to dairy, and I still drink it, but I have found that for me milk is a weight loss killer. It could be a combination of things. I'd say ditch the milk for a stretch and see if that is the issue, especially if the milk is early in the morning when the 'dawn effect' is in play with blood glucose. The milk (sugars) will push that glucose level up and then the insulin response creates insulin resistance over time. Battling insulin resistance can be an uphill battle is so many things that affect our health, weight loss being one of the primary ones. Good luck. Keep pushing. Scott

Yesterday was leftover a left over T-Bone and eggs, four scrambled. OMAD and the satiety of red meat can be crazy at times. I walked yesterday morning just shy of 3.5 miles with some pushups along the way. I showered and went to the shop working on two old truck projects (needed them like I needed another hole in my head). I worked pretty much all day between the two and then came in around 6PM. I logged on to the internet, let the TV play and looked for more parts for my two trucks. At bedtime around 9PM eating had not crossed my mind since earlier that morning. It is 4AM, on the way to the gym and the morning walk, and not the least bit hungry. 20-ish some hours without eating and I'm not hungry, nor have the wheels fell off. Crazy. Scott

I agree with "to attain repentance" but the darker side of me in these situations has no problem setting up the appointment. But, for him to have to listen to Charlie Kirk 24/7/365 would be fitting. LOL Scott

Good video. So much truth. Division is for sure the most powerful weapon in the world. I'm like Bob, I'm not all that active in politics. Probably should know more than I do. Scott

I read a similar article the other day basically saying keto (but they refuse to say carnivore, LOL) lessens the occurrences of depression and anxiety. I was at work and maybe half way thru I was interrupted by someone wanting me to do what I get paid to do. The nerve of some people. Interesting. Scott

I try to live right and maybe the furthest down the rabbit hole I go to is the punishments for senseless crimes. I pretty much lose my membership to the human race with my views. I would pass a law today that said the platform in which Charlie Kirk will remain in place. The only thing that can be done with that platform is to make sure the overhead structure will hold at least 250lbs of static weight. When the culprit looked down as he swung, as his last breath is drawn, he can look down and the last sight he would see would be the blood he spilled. Just not for Charlie Kirk but there are literally thousands of crimes in our country that I would plug into the above ceremony. This man was killed for exercising his right to free speech. I have watched no telling how many of his videos and probably agree with him the majority of the time. If someone does not believe in homosexuality does not make them a homophobe. If I choose not to acknowledge someone as a pronoun, or them/they, it does not make me a bad person. I believe that person has every right to pursue life in route they choose. I spent six years in the military along side, both before and after, millions of men and women that has afforded us the rights we cherish. I don't believe I have the right to vote to tell other people how to live, even if I don't believe in their particular point of view. We should be able to get along. Thoughts and prayers to Charlie Kirk's wife and two small children. Hopefully they wind up in a better world than their father left. Scott

If I have a half a steak left, I put it in the fridge for the next morning on the way home from the gym. No knife, no fork, no plate. Just teeth ripping thru meat coming down the highway. I'm not sure if that is any closer to cavemen but I am sure I look like a psycho coming down the highway. Scott

They do have a point if it came from the internet. People are not allowed to lie or deceive on the internet. I read it in the by-laws. Scott

Me too. I must have missed this class in my Google medical degree program as well as my Youtube College of Medicine degree. Scott

I never heard of it referred to as alpha-gal. My buddy has it and referred to it more as a derivative of Lyme disease. He ate at a fast food restaurant, got on his Harley-Davidson and on the way back to the body shop started losing consciousness and blurry vision. He coasted up into the fire department and laid his bike over at their front door. I think they treated him with epinephrin and then on to the hospital. It took several weeks to identify his trigger. His faded in time for the most part but every so often red meat will cause him issues. I just never heard of it referred to this way. Was sort of lost. Scott

Me too. I think I actually learned that from you after bumping heads a couple times. This was all unsolicited and they all seemed interested. If nothing else it was good fellowship and good conversation. If it were to go any further they can only help themselves. Scott

Still so impressed with eating plus 16oz steaks. Sort of envious. Scott

Another thread on how difficult it can be to 'spread the word' or give 'my testimony' on the benefits of eating carnivore. Last night we went to a local bar in a small town not too far from here. One of our friend's has a band and they have since moved to Nashville but are home now for a stretch. Their daughter who is pursuing a solo career in Nashville was home as well and it was a family affair of really good music. Babbling. In between sets or songs, the 'old people' were discussing all their ailments. As each told of their medical issues my wife and eye would make eye contact, and I would have a little smile. Then the next, and then the next. My buddy asked why, so my wife explained I was not laughing at their issues, but it was an inside joke between my wife and me. Every time I hear of someone getting sick, discovering an "aging issue", dieting/weight loss, etc. etc. I say to my wife "Carnivore Diet". To the point now it is a running joke. To show how far it goes last week she came home from work and told me the Jeep's check engine light came on and the engine had a minor stalling at takeoff. I told her it would easily be solved with the 'carnivore diet'. She is about tired of hearing 'carnivore'. LOL Again, babbling on. I was telling our table how many positives I have had with doing not much more than switching my diet. It is a hard sell to tell people that what you eat is only a drop in the bucket compared to the effects of 'what you stop eating'. Strange concept for most. And true to form, my niece had her phone out 'fact checking' just about my every statement. "I can eat all the ribeye I want and drink water, from that I will lose weight and have a better metabolic health?" And when I said YES, our table was fully engulfed. Maybe an hour or so answering questions the best I could, having my niece fact check and report back to the table that I was not near as crazy in the head as I sounded. My wife is on another attempt and she is about 7 days in of eating carnivore/strict carnivore and did the immediate switch to one meal a day (I think it is better to sort of let that happen on its own, but for her I think it is more of a diet hack than a long-term change, so we are rolling with her new plan). As soon as she said she had lost 6lbs in a week the other ladies at the table are all carnivores starting today. Maybe til lunch, or supper, LOL but hopefully they will give it a try. Waiting for the gym to open and passing the time. Hope everyone has a great weekend. Scott

I broke the fast with salmon and butter. Either I'm adjusting or the salmon ends up being the food of choice to breaking the fast. I had a minor bout in the bathroom yesterday, but nothing compared to the times before. So, for me, yesterday was salmon and butter. Today I am back amongst the eating. Scott

I will give that a try. I tried scrambled eggs coming off one of the earlier fasts but I think I may have eaten too much. Not sure. Everything else, a little or a lot, and it was off to the races. Still trying to dial in coming off the fast. Hopefully the boiled eggs will be different. Thanks. Scott

I doubt that. I do pretty good with the fasting but I have yet to master the art of breaking the fast. I get really loose regardless of how I try to come out of it. Eating a lot, eating a little, broth to start, then a smaller meal later, different meats but it all the same. Fast, get super loose and then normalize within the week. Still a work in progress. Scott

Nothing today. Nor tomorrow. Maybe Friday. Maybe Saturday. Depends on how I feel. Scott

Welcome. I agree with Geezy. Yours is a great story. The very things that you were eating that were deemed good for you were trying to do you in. Once we cut out the things we weren't designed to eat and then center our way of eating around the things we were intended to eat it is absolutely amazing the benefits. Congrats. And again, welcome. Scott

Thanks. Carnivore has been amazing for me in so many ways. Before, I could my steak, half my wife's steak, a loaded baked potato with a double order of green beans, three or four glasses of sweet tea and then a big bowl of ice cream before bed. Now, I struggle to eat a whole steak. 14-16 oz is just about max for me and from there it is pretty much the next day before I am hungry again. All the weight loss and healing has been quite the positive but I look back and see how much food I ate per day. (And since I'm super cheap in everything I do the first thing I see is how much money I wasted chasing phantom hunger signals. I was paying cash to pummel my body. I guess I'm smart like that. LOL Congrats on your progresses as well. Scott

Pretty much the same boat. I dropped 95lbs and it was a sickly/puny look. Mostly for an autoimmune disease but sarcopenia as well I lift three to four times per week. A couple to three times per week I walk around 3.5 miles. One day just walking, one day with a 40lb weight vest and the third day I try to get into 125 or so push-ups along the way. My problem is that I struggle to eat the amount of protein needed for muscles gain. Depending on the source it can range from 0.7 to 1.5 grams of protein per pound of lean body mass. I'm guessing I need to be around 200 grams of protein per day. I have struggled to eat that much in a day. I added protein powder to get in a few extra grams, and it helped. I ran out once and substituted a store-bought protein shake. It had 11-12 grams of sugar and after I drank a 1/3 of the bottle within an hour, I was hungry. I used that hunger to eat another steak or another source of protein. I gained about 9-10lbs over a month. I am sure it was mostly fat and water weight, but I did see significant gains in the gym. As the young folks say, "the plates don't lie". Maybe a little of that weight was lean muscle mass but the gains in the gym were significant, especially for a 56 year old guy that went the last 30 years without any sort of cardio nor resistance training (and ate the very bottom of the dumpster diet to boot). I have hovered around the 80-90lb lost mark for the last several months. There is some weight left to lose but it is not as big a concern for me as of late. Scott

I think they have their place. I have seen and experienced their shortcomings as well. I also think a lot of us wouldn't still be kicking if it were not for them (and maybe some that are not here because of them). I think the biggest problem is that we learned as well as we were taught to hold the profession in the highest regard. And at one time it was a true calling for the people who practiced medicine. The days of house calls and trading out services for home repairs or meals or food supplies is long gone. When I was a kid in the town over form us was a doctor who say up his practice in his house. It was the scariest examination room I have ever seen. He had every book ever printed by man stacked up all over the room. So much so I always thought he would die from the pending avalanche. The stacks were always leaning and as a kid, I swear they were swaying. He charged $2 per visit. As he was giving me a physical to play youth football, he said he didn't understand why young men would bruise their brains on purpose. While examining he noticed I had athlete's foot pretty bad on one foot. My mom explained the family doctor had prescribed this and that but it kept coming back. She had tried different detergents, different socks, and as any good mother would do, ensured his I was bathing. LOL He told he to go home take the prescriptions and toss them int he garbage. Fill a foot tub with water just as hot as I could stand it and then add two cups of white vinegar. Within a day it was healing, and withing a week it was gone and maybe one case since (but I knew the fix). As a twelve year old I remember him telling my mom that if it were not for the doctors the pharmacists would starve to death. I had zero understanding of how money can sway the noblest of professions. Our health now plays second, and even third fiddle to Big Pharma and Big Food. They use money in order to use doctors to send us astray. The key to their successes has been using the messenger that we were taught to trust the most. It was a beautiful plan and wildly successful. Scott

I am sure if I ate some bread or pasta or sweet cakes, I would turn into a fiend all over again. 11-12 grams of sugar over a couple days made me hungry. It feels like hunger but could possibly be a craving. Sugar requesting more sugar? I don't know. When I first quit drinking, I had no issues being around others that were drinking or even going to bars/clubs. Then one night we were in a bar and as the waitress walked by there were long neck bottle of Budweiser on her tray. It would have been an excellent commercial. As she walked by, I could not only see the beads of condensation running down the bottle but I could just about read the label from distance. LOL It was calling me. I had to leave or I would have took a header right off the side of the 'proverbial wagon'. This 11-12 grams of sugar over a couple days has shown me that sugar had a hold on me and maybe it still does (even though I made the switch with relative ease/no cravings). Scott

I am on my second stint of the lion diet. The first time I genuinely felt better. I have an autoimmune disease (NMO/SD) which is similar to MS. The "all-red meat" diet in the 50's was used with a lot of success for MS patients. This second stint I am not so sure I feel anything different after a month or so. I had bloodwork done just before switching from carnivore to the Lion version and I will have more at the end of September. Maybe I see the needle move in some of my results then but right now, sort of feels the same as regular carnivore. @Bob I can't speak to the kidneys and protein with any real experience, but this is what I am thinking on more of a general basis and it goes to previous conversations/threads on wading thru the medical research that is now readily available. Is protein bad for the kidneys? I think not so much if you have healthy kidneys to start with and you have a diet and a lifestyle that promotes the positive use of proteins. I think the same with cholesterol. Is LDL and higher cholesterol a bad thing? I think probably not, if on a diet somewhere between keto and carnivore (and maybe closer to carnivore) If we just eat a load of crap, and amongst that load is a lot of protein, I am sure that is taxing on the kidneys. Since red meat and a high fat diet is absolutely taboo to the majority of the world, especially the medical professions, The first conclusion is that it is the protein (red meat) that is damaging the kidneys. Which, just like LDL and heart disease, could be technically true. If we eat a diet that keeps us close to the ketosis mark and even pushes us into the lower ends of ketosis on a regular basis, we become fat adaptive. We are using the fat, and it is not laying around in stores. Higher fat in the blood stream can be expected but it is moving to be used vs. being stored. Same with the kidneys and the proteins. The kidney is fine with protein until it has to work thru a ton of 'crap' before the proteins get there and if dehydrated, it is another ball game altogether. But like LDL, proteins (meat/fats) are the easiest culprit to sell. I think also that is why the health issues that get fixed with carnivore is such a broad spectrum. Sometimes I even forget the health is coming from what we are not eating much more so than the fats/proteins that we are eating. If I fill my gas tank with half gas and half water, I am going to have all kinds of problems. If I drain the tank and fill it up with just gas most would think the gas fixed the problems when in reality, not adding water is the true fix. (dumbed it way down-but that is how my brain works) Babbling at work waiting for the day to get rolling. Scott