Skip to content

Welcome to our Carnivore / Ketovore / Keto Online Community!

Welcome to Carnivore Talk! An online community of people who have discovered the benefits of an carnviore-centric ketogenic diet with the goal of losing weight, optimizing their health, and supporting and encouraging one another. We warmly welcome you! [Read More]

Red meat does not cause cancer

The "research" that claims to show red meat causes cancer is usually a questionnaire and they don't separate meat from processed meat.

It's pseudoscience masquerading as science that the average Joe believes is real science so they get fooled.

There is no link between red meat consumption and increased risk of cancers of any kind.

(It's impossible to do actual science for any diet anyway because you'd need to test with identical twins and control every variable in their life except for their diets. That is obviously not ever going to be done due to ethical reasons.)

  • Replies 7
  • Views 390
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • True that. I agree that it doesn't, and also that it's impossible to test. Problem #1 is food frequency questionaries are not reliable by any means. Problem #2 is these meat eating survey participants

  • Scott F.
    Scott F.

    When the studies say 'observational' or 'surveyed' I lose interest and a lot of times stop reading at that point. I like data, actual data, and how it speaks to certain issues. I think observational

Featured Replies

True that. I agree that it doesn't, and also that it's impossible to test.

On 10/12/2026 at 4:06 AM, Vynith said:

The "research" that claims to show red meat causes cancer is usually a questionnaire and they don't separate meat from processed meat

Problem #1 is food frequency questionaries are not reliable by any means.

Problem #2 is these meat eating survey participants probably bring along a host of confounders, like eating processed grains, sugars, smoking, being a couch potato, etc.

And then it's worth noting that there IS a difference between processed meat and fresh meat. But how much difference and how important is the difference? According to Dr. Ken Berry, meat is meat, and the sodium nitrate in processed meat is nothing to fear so go ahead and enjoy your bacon. He even says you could do a carnivore diet effectively on just hot dogs and bologna if that is all you could afford.

  • 3 weeks later...

I think discussions about red meat and cancer need to consider the overall evidence rather than relying on one study or headline. Factors such as portion size, cooking methods, frequency of consumption, and overall dietary patterns all matter. It's also important to distinguish between fresh red meat and processed meat, since research has found different levels of risk associated with them. A balanced diet and healthy lifestyle are worth considering when looking at long-term health.

The studies are nice reads at times and even, when they are pro 'my way of thinking', I still take it with a grain of salt.

I feel like the overwhelming majority of the studies are started with an agenda, and also fell like the studies that are published fit the original agenda. Those that didn't seem to get shelved. It feels that way for both sides of any study.

I'm in the pharmaceutical business. We have to everything the same way every time or it is rejected. That is 100% accuracy (as it should be/as it has to be). I have that 100% mindset in a lot of things, and especially the studies. A study will come out and say 68% of people that did blah blah blah became cancer patients. My first thought is that why didn't they double down on the next study on the 32% people who didn't.

You are 27% more likely to have blah blah blah if you do this or that. What about the 73% of people who did not have issues with blah blah blah, and what are they doing differently.

Understanding my approach is flawed to studies, it does help me read both sides and not have an overboard reaction to either side.

Scott

13 hours ago, georgeorwell469 said:

Factors such as portion size, cooking methods, frequency of consumption, and overall dietary patterns all matter.

You said portion size matters when it comes to red meat and cancer. How, exactly?

Is there a dose-response relationship in the studies you’re thinking of, or is this just the usual ‘everything in moderation’ line?

Which papers are you referring to?

2 hours ago, Bob said:

You said portion size matters when it comes to red meat and cancer. How, exactly?

Is there a dose-response relationship in the studies you’re thinking of, or is this just the usual ‘everything in moderation’ line?

Which papers are you referring to?

That's a fair challenge, Bob. I should have been more specific about the research I was referring to.

One paper worth looking at is the systematic review and dose-response meta-analysis published in the Annals of Oncology in 2017, titled "Foods and beverages and colorectal cancer risk." It analyzed prospective studies and reported an approximately 12% increase in relative colorectal cancer risk for each additional 100 g per day of combined red and processed meat consumption.

There is also an important distinction between the two types of meat. The WHO/IARC assessment estimated an 18% increase in relative colorectal cancer risk for every 50 g of processed meat consumed daily. For red meat, the estimate was 17% per additional 100 g daily, but WHO made clear that this estimate was conditional on the association being causal.

I also found the World Cancer Research Fund's evidence review, which explains the difference in the strength of evidence for red and processed meat.

I agree that these findings need to be interpreted carefully. These are observational data, not proof that eating a particular portion of fresh beef will cause cancer in an individual. Relative risk also isn't the same as absolute risk.

So I wouldn't say that portion size establishes a precise safe or unsafe threshold. My point was that habitual intake and the distinction between fresh and processed meat are relevant when evaluating the available evidence.

I appreciate you asking for specific papers. It's a much better discussion when we can look at the actual numbers and limitations rather than relying on headlines or general statements.

When the studies say 'observational' or 'surveyed' I lose interest and a lot of times stop reading at that point. I like data, actual data, and how it speaks to certain issues.

I think observational and surveyed studies fall into one half of 'causation and correlation' and in that half it is a lot of assumptions and speculations.

And at the same time, I factor how I feel and how I am doing and will rank that above any data that says my strict carnivore, primarily red meat, salt and water will have adverse effects at some point.

Good topic.

Scott

On 11/4/2026 at 11:41 PM, georgeorwell469 said:

I agree that these findings need to be interpreted carefully. These are observational data, not proof that eating a particular portion of fresh beef will cause cancer in an individual. Relative risk also isn't the same as absolute risk.

So I wouldn't say that portion size establishes a precise safe or unsafe threshold.

We’re on the same page there. The dose-response numbers from those meta-analyses are real as far as relative risk goes, but they don’t establish that any given amount of fresh beef causes cancer in any individual, and the absolute risk differences are small.

Where I part ways is treating “habitual intake and the fresh-vs-processed distinction” as the main takeaway that should guide people here. Those observational signals come mostly from mixed diets heavy in processed foods, and they haven’t held up as a practical concern for people eating primarily fresh red meat while cutting out the refined carbohydrates and other factors that travel with higher meat intake in the general population. A lot of us have watched liver enzymes, insulin, and other markers improve on higher fresh-meat intakes—the opposite of what a straightforward reading of the relative-risk figures would predict.

So yes, interpret the epidemiology carefully. Just don’t let the careful interpretation quietly default back to “therefore limit fresh red meat.”

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Featured Content

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.